Hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) have been promoted as a decarbonisation solution for decades.
In 2003, US President Bush’s state of the union called for an historic 1.2 billion dollars in research for hydrogen-powered automobiles. BMW has pursued hydrogen passenger vehicles since 1979 without ever bringing a model to the market, producing only prototypes. The Toyota Mirai FCEV was introduced in 2014, a little later than the Tesla Model S Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV) in 2012.
Yet in 2025, around 21 million BEVs were sold and only around 16,000 FCEVs – just 0.076% of BEV sales. Heavy trucks, touted by many as one of the prime users of green hydrogen, are not taking off. Here also, battery electric trucks have clearly taken the lead. Transit buses follow a similar path.
In this blog post, we will answer the question: why is it that BEVs are succeeding over hydrogen vehicles?
Lower efficiency and higher costs
First of all, BEVs are far more energy efficient than FCEVs. Of every kilowatt hour (kWh) of green energy produced, around 69% reaches the wheel of a BEV, while this drops to around 23% for an FCEV due to many conversion steps. This makes a BEV around three times more efficient than an FCEV – which means a 3 times lower energy use per mile driven. Furthermore, based on a green hydrogen price of $15 per kg, the cost per mile for an FCEV will be five times higher than a BEV. The current price of green hydrogen is far higher, varying from €16.95-€19.95 in Europe.
The purchasing price of a hydrogen vehicle is also far higher than a battery electric vehicle due to its complicated technology. In Germany, the current base purchasing price of a Toyota Mirai is €68,490 and €69.900 for a Hyundai NEXO – the only two hydrogen models currently on the market. Battery electric models are already available from €18,700.
Efficiency drops even lower in a second type of hydrogen car distinct from FCEVs, known as Hydrogen Internal Combustion Engine Vehicles (H2-ICEVs). Burning hydrogen in a combustion engine leads to 4.5 times lower efficiency than in a BEV, alongside an associated increase in fuel costs. On top of that, combustion engines running on hydrogen produce nitrogen oxide (NOX) emissions, which include the potent, durable greenhouse gas nitrous oxide (N2O). NOX emissions pose serious health risks and can lead to respiratory ailments like asthma, emphysema and bronchitis.
Though some argue that fossil fuel cars succeeded over BEVs in the early 1900s despite their low efficiency, much has since changed. Lead acid batteries once had a very limited range and lifetime, while fossil fuels’ enormous energy density made it very easy to transport and store. Nature has produced fossil oil over millions of years, meaning we only need to extract and refine it, which costs around 17-19% of the energy of a barrel of oil – making it extremely cheap and efficiency less of a concern. But producing green hydrogen costs enormous amounts of green energy to produce (50-65 kWh for one kg of hydrogen), making efficiency a primary concern as it relates directly to costs.
For trucks, three to five times higher operating costs are simply not an option, with average profit margins for transporters sitting around just 1.5 to 3 percent in Europe.
Increased maintenance costs
Hydrogen vehicles involve far more complicated technology, which means higher purchase price and maintenance costs.
A Toyota Mirai FCEV has a service maintenance interval of 5,000 miles (based on US scheduled maintenance), which is mainly inspections – for instance, checking for hydrogen leak. As hydrogen is stored under extreme high pressure at 700 bar or 10,000 PSI, and is the smallest molecule in the universe, the risk of leaks is substantial.
Conversely, a Tesla Model 3 has its first maintenance after 12,500 miles to clean and lubricate the brake callipers – but only if it has been driven on salty roads in the winter. Thereafter, the interior filter is changed every two years and brake fluid inspected every 4 years.
FCEVs also need special and expensive air filters to protect its fuel cell from the smallest particles. In order to absorb harmful gases from the air, the filter is also equipped with active carbon layers or other adsorbent media to bind harmful gases. The requirements for air filtration are considerably higher for fuel cells than for combustion engines, and are consequently more expensive. Fuel cell catalysts also degrade through use and contamination, requiring costly replacement.
Charging flexibility and refuelling costs
Electric vehicles are far more flexible to charge than hydrogen vehicles. Many people can charge their BEV at home or at work. There were already more than one million public chargers in Europe in 2025 and 5 million worldwide, with numbers fast increasing. The year-on-year growth of charging infrastructure was 55% from 2021 to 2024. With vehicle-to-grid and vehicle-to-home technology, EVs can even be used as a stationary battery.
Hydrogen filling stations, on the other hand, are extremely expensive and far less flexible, with a 350 bar hydrogen refuelling station costing between 1.8 million and 3.2 million euros depending on size. There are far fewer operational hydrogen filling stations in Europe – only 179 in May 2026 – and many are closing due to very low utilisation. Globally, there are only around 1,000 hydrogen refuelling stations in operation.
Public chargers for BEVs are far cheaper: they cost between $200 for a level one charger and $70,000-$200,000 for a level three charger. This makes a level three charger 15-45 times cheaper than the largest hydrogen refuelling station.
Then there is the problem of getting the hydrogen to the refuelling station, which can either be done by truck or pipeline. First of all, there are no hydrogen pipelines to refuel stations, and in most countries the gas grid is not suitable for transporting hydrogen. This means that the hydrogen will be transported by trucks to the refuelling stations. This will increase the number of deliveries to a refuelling station by a factor of at least 6, and as much as 30 times for compressed hydrogen deliveries, and the costs will ultimately be passed on to the customer. With battery electric vehicles, there is no need to transport fuel to refuelling stations.
Decreased payload?
Another argument, especially regarding electric trucks, is that the battery weight reduces the amount of payload the truck can transport. However, the majority of trucks (66%) are limited by volume and not weight, meaning the extra battery weight is not a problem. Just 25% of transports are frequently limited by weight. A considerable amount of these transports are fuel transports to refuelling stations, which will reduce as battery electric vehicles increase. As explained in the previous section, with hydrogen trucks these transports would increase by a factor of six to 30 times. For the remaining 24%, transports are only sometimes limited by weight, with an average weight reduction of just 1-4%. As a result, battery weight reduces just a small percentage of transport payload.
Furthermore, battery energy density per unit of weight is increasing. We have a new learning rate, the cost reduction every time cumulative manufacturing volume doubles, of 18% per year. So in the foreseeable future, this weight problem will disappear for the remaining 10-24%.
Passenger hydrogen vehicles also have a considerably smaller boot space compared to battery electric vehicles due to the lower energy/volume relationship of hydrogen and large compressed hydrogen tanks. At 350 bar and taking into account the conversion efficiency of hydrogen to electricity in the fuelcell, the energy density of hydrogen per unit volume is actually about the same as that of a Tesla battery – but the form factor of hydrogen tanks is poorer, i.e. they must be cylinders with hemispherical ends and don’t pack together very well. Thus a Toyota Mirai has a boot space of 321 litres, while a Tesla Model 3 has boot space of 425 litres.
Longer range and reduced refuelling times
A common argument in favour of FCEVs is their longer range and reduced refuelling times – so let’s examine the difference between an FCEV and a BEV. A Toyota Mirai has a Worldwide Harmonised Light Vehicle Test Procedure (WLTP – a global laboratory test standard used to measure fuel consumption, emissions and driving range) range of 650 km. A Tesla Model 3 Long Range has a WLTP range of 750 km – so offers a slightly longer range at a lower price (€68,490 for a Toyota Mirai and €45,970 for a Tesla Model 3 Long Range, German prices 2026).
Another point worth remembering: the average driving distance is not long. In the most car-loving country, the United States, just a tiny fraction of daily trips are above 100 miles (161 km). And as stated earlier, battery density is increasing, and so will the range of BEVs as a result.
Trucks have longer daily trips. Of the hydrogen-powered trucks on the market above 12 tons of weight, one of the few models commercially available is the Hyundai Xcient FCEV. It stores 31 kgs of hydrogen for which it can drive 400 km with a full load. It can be refuelled in 8-20 minutes, which is indeed fast. But it comes with the drawback of there being few hydrogen refuelling stations available, and without the flexibility of warehouse charging, unlike BEVs.
For battery electric trucks, there are far more models to choose from. The Mercedes eActros 600 has a range of 500 km on a single charge with a full load, which is further than the Hyundai FCEV. A Tesla Semi has a range of 800 km with a full load, and Volvo Trucks has officially launched a new long-distance electric truck, the FH Aero Electric with extended range, capable of driving up to 700 km on one charge. Furthermore, battery electric trucks can be charged with a mega charger from 20-80% in half an hour. With regulations in Europe mandating 45 minutes of rest every 4 hours and 30 minutes of driving for truck drivers, these charging times are well within limits.
To mention other solutions, Janus Electric in Australia has even developed a battery swapping system with the ability to change a 620 kWh battery in 4 minutes with an ordinary forklift.
Hydrogen safety
Hydrogen is the smallest molecule in the universe, and more prone to leakage compared to other fuels. Its flammability range is 4-75% when mixed with air, and it is explosive from 18-59%. This is a far higher range than for gasoline, which has a flammability range of just 1-6%. The ignition energy required for hydrogen is also 14 times lower compared to gasoline, and its burn rate is 7.5 times greater – meaning that it can generate more damaging explosions when ignited inside a confined space. Hydrogen fires are invisible to the naked eye in daylight.
Due to these properties, handling of hydrogen requires highly skilled, trained professionals and special tools. NASA has a 390-page document for the handling and storing of hydrogen. There are many documented cases of leaks, explosions or fires at hydrogen refuelling stations, including in Norway, the Netherlands, South Korea and the United States.
The chance of a battery fire in a car is 20 to 60 times lower than a fire in a gasoline-powered car.
Conclusion
While hydrogen once appeared to be the only viable option for a decarbonised transport fuel, the invention and commercialisation of the lithium ion battery and the commercial success of electric vehicles has more or less ended hydrogen’s future in transport.
The commercial failure of hydrogen for cars and light trucks is already complete, and the evidence from commercial trials supports the conclusion that hydrogen will similarly fail as a transport fuel option for heavier vehicles such as trucks, buses and trains.
This failure is due to the physical properties of hydrogen and the laws of physics underpinning hydrogen production – neither of which are amenable to change by innovation. Public expenditure related to hydrogen transport would therefore be better spent on electrification.